The controversy over the electoral college system
The electoral college is the system, outlined in the constitution, of choosing, or electing, the president of the united states many americans believe this process is unfair, and it has come under intense controversy in recent years. The electoral college system is frequently called into question, particularly when the winner of the electoral college is not the winner of the popular vote the post editors found fault with the system back in 1934, yet not much has changed in the last 84 years. There is much controversy over the electoral college and whether there should be a new system of electing the president of the united states put into effect. In the electoral college system, the states serve as the centurial groups (though they are not, of course, based on wealth), and the number of votes per state is determined by the size of each state's congressional delegation. In the electoral college cleveland, carrying the swing states of new york, new jersey, connecticut, and indiana, garnered 277 votes to harrison’s 145 1896: william mckinley vs william jennings.
A constitutional defense of the electoral college and the election of the american president timothy s boylan participation in the united states over the last century however, calls for a system of presidential selection based on a the debate over the electoral college can therefore be framed as. The electoral college has been an issue of great debate for a long period of time recently the governor of illinois signed into effect a bill that would give the state's electoral votes to the winner of the nation-wide popular election. Opponents of the electoral college system also point to the risk of so-called faithless electors a faithless elector is one who is pledged to vote for his party's candidate for president but nevertheless votes of another candidate. The electoral college system gave more weight to smaller states in the election process, as part of a broader compromise to get southern pro-slavery states and smaller states to approve the constitution.
The electoral college is a hybrid of direct democracy no candidate would have won without the popular vote the ec works on a confusing mix of politics and the public vote is a key part of that. Controversial elections all 73 democratic-republican members of the electoral college voted faithfully, casting two votes each, one for jefferson and one for burr this election was clearly corrupted and has found a place in every debate over the electoral college since. The founding fathers would more than likely be surprised by the current controversy over the electoral college provisions of the constitution indeed, it was one of the least controversial provisions of the new compact during the divisive debate for ratification. Here’s a quick list of the problems and potential problems.
Despite the popular vote, president-elect donald trump won the most electoral college votes and secured his seat as the 45th president of the united states of america on nov 9. The controversy over the electoral college system a number of americans fail to realize that when they vote they are not voting for the president and vice-president directly, but for electors who then cast their ballots in the electoral college. The electoral college prevents pluralities (no candidate getting a full 50% of the vote) by requiring half-plus-one of the electoral votes for anyone to be elected president.
Debate over the system used to choose the president and vice president of the united states is as old as the us constitution itself critics of the electoral college system call it a relic. The electoral college system encourages candidates to pander to the interests of voters in a few closely contested states 5 the electoral college system, especially in a close election, is subject to the mischief that might be caused by disloyal--or even bribed--electors. Debate over the electoral college revived again his first term because of electoral college math -- the sum of 51 separate elections in 50 states and washington, dc whereby each polity will. Elimination of the electoral college would provide this opportunity because it would likely lead to the demise of our stable two-party system in a multi-party system, candidates are no longer striving for a majority (or even a large plurality) of anything, be it individuals’ or states’ votes. I will argue that the electoral college is a fair system that is necessary to american politics to keep a fair representation the opponent will argue that it must be reformed or abolished.
The controversy over the electoral college system
Electoral college: electoral college, the system by which the president and vice president of the united states are chosen it was devised by the framers of the united states constitution to provide a method of election that was feasible, desirable, and consistent with a republican form of government for the results. The united states electoral college is a body of electors established by the united states constitution, constituted every four years for the sole purpose of electing the president and vice president of the united statesthe college consists of 538 electors, and an absolute majority of 270 electoral votes is required to win an election pursuant to article ii, section 1, clause 2, the. This is the rhode island election ticket for the electors for the hayes-wheeler republican ticket george h corliss, the famous rhode island inventor, was disqualified as an elector, creating an electoral college controversy. The results of the 2016 presidential election in which the electoral vote did not match the so-called popular vote has predictably resulted in demands for the abolition of the electoral college.
The electoral college is controversial because it is, in some ways, undemocratic there are a couple of ways in which this is true first, it allows for us to end up with one candidate winning the. The electoral college method of choosing the president and vice president guarantees that each state, whether large or small in area or population, has some voice in selecting the nation’s leaders. Debating the merits of the electoral college the 2000 presidential election revived a long-standing debate over the electoral college as the nation braces for the possibility of another disputed.
Should the electoral college be replaced by the direct election of the president a debate the direct election of the president a debate theodore s arrington saul brenner will defend the present electoral college system affirmative in this affirmative argument i will show that: (1) the electoral college is. Four times in us history, the winner of the nationwide popular vote has lost the electoral college and the general election but a proposal called the national popular vote interstate compact.